Title: We Are Not Ok
Author: Natália Gomes
Genre: General (Adult) Fiction, YA, Teens
Publisher: HQ Young Adult, HQ
Release Date: 2nd May 2019
BLURB from Goodreads
If only they could have spoken out.
Lucy thinks she’s better than the other girls.
Maybe if she’s pointing fingers at everyone else, no one will see the secret she’s hiding.
Ulana comes from a conservative Muslim family where reputation is everything. One rumour -
true or false – can destroy futures.
Trina likes to party. She’s kissed a lot of boys. She’s even shown her red bra to one. But she didn’t consent to that
night at Lucy’s party. So why doesn’t anyone believe
her?
Sophia loved her boyfriend. She did anything for him, even send him photos of herself. So why is she the one being pointed at in the hallways, laughed at, spat at when it was him who betrayed her trust?
PURCHASE LINKS
REVIEW
The overwhelming feeling you get from each girl is that they are not happy, they want more than they have. It seems all of the girls are wanting to be like one of the others as well as more than they currently are. Which I guess lots of teenagers, in fact, most teenagers go through this kind of thing. The writing is very true to life and different parts of the story are told by the individual girls that section is about. There were times I wanted to shout at the different girls or shake them by the shoulders, but then I am well past being a teenager myself. I readily admit to feeling the pressure of wanting to fit in. Envying the popular pretty girls and wanting the fit boys to notice you too, rather than treating you like "one of the boys" or "one of the gang".
There is a kind of "the moral of this story is..." aspect to this book when the girls at the end of the book come to a realisation that things could have been so different much sooner, if only they had spoken to each other.
I
never used to read much from the contemporary genre whether it be YA or Adult
but for some reason this book caught my eye, I read the blurb and felt I really
wanted to read it.
I
find the cover rather simplistic yet striking. I love the colours on the cover
and the large X makes you want to know what is being said is "no or banned". So I guess
it tugs on your curiosity/nosey gene lol. At the very beginning of the book is
a playlist of songs, I’ll be totally honest I haven’t heard of most of the
artists, so can’t say I know any of the songs, perhaps they will be more
relevant to the YA market this book is aimed at. I think the byline hints at whats to come in the book very well, "Four Girls, Four Voices, All Unheard". It is the perfect byline! I love a great byline.
The
book is focused on four girls, Sophia Greer, Lucy McNeil, Ulana Alami and
Trina Davis all seemingly similar and attending the same school. Yet looking at
each different girl you learn all the individual secrets they have to keep....
It
is a difficult book to describe and talk about without revealing too much of
the plot, but I will try my best and share a little bit about each girl.
Sophia
has a steady boyfriend, Steve, and is happy in their relationship but Steve
wants to push things further than just kissing and touching under shirt. Sophia
is managing to come up with excuses not to go any further but worries Steve
will get fed up of her saying no and look elsewhere for the kind of relationship
he wants. Then she wonders is she is saying no and isn’t ready, is it that
Steve isn’t “the one” for her and does she just need to pluck up the courage
and “do it”? To be fair Steve doesn’t push Sophia, yet at the same time wants
to know if she will be saying “yes” soon or not? Sophia thinks about what she
would call her own “short comings” in comparison to other girls at Birchwood
High School. Sophia isn’t as fun and social as Trina, or as confident, pretty or
popular as Lucy.
Lucy
McNeill may appear confident but she feels different, she thinks everything
seems different this year. Her dad has once again left the family home, he has
another woman, in fact his girlfriend is pregnant! Lucy compares her father’s
girlfriend Amber, to someone who she reminds her of from school. To Lucy people
like Amber and Trina are the same, in her opinion they are sluts who steal others
boyfriends/husbands. These “sluts” also wear short skirts and wear far too much
make-up too. Even though Lucy thinks this way she cannot seem to be able to finish her relationship with Steve and ends up buying some lacy underwear and posing in it, then sending photos to Steve. At this stage I was "woah! alarm bells!" and "Oh you silly girl"
Trina
Davis hasn’t got a very good reputation at school and Lucy blames her for “stealing”
her boyfriend Rhys. Trina has been seeing Rhys during the school holidays and
hopes their relationship continues, she doesn’t see what Rhys ever saw in his ex-girlfriend.
Trina hates that everyone sees her as the bad person, they think she stole
Rhys! Trina and Lucy used to be kind of friends, well they used to have quite a
few classes together. Trina cannot understand why Lucy should have any ill
feeling towards her, its not like she stole Rhys. As far as Trina knows Rhys
and Lucy had finished their relationship before Rhys went out with her!
Ulana
is a Muslim girl whose family is strict and all she wishes is to have some of
the freedom the other girls seem to have. Ulana has a secret boyfriend, Aiden.
They try to have “proper dates” but have to be extra careful not to be seen. Ulana
explains to Aiden that her family would not approve purely because he is not a “good
muslim boy”, they are “not the same”, they “should not mix” Then Ulana meets
Aiden’s family and it seems that her family isn’t the other one with prejudices
about who their child should and shouldn’t date.
The overwhelming feeling you get from each girl is that they are not happy, they want more than they have. It seems all of the girls are wanting to be like one of the others as well as more than they currently are. Which I guess lots of teenagers, in fact, most teenagers go through this kind of thing. The writing is very true to life and different parts of the story are told by the individual girls that section is about. There were times I wanted to shout at the different girls or shake them by the shoulders, but then I am well past being a teenager myself. I readily admit to feeling the pressure of wanting to fit in. Envying the popular pretty girls and wanting the fit boys to notice you too, rather than treating you like "one of the boys" or "one of the gang".
I
really loved one of the entries in Trina’s diary about why is it when you don’t
want to see someone, all you do is see them everywhere you go lol. Whereas
Ulana is having the opposite experience of when you really need to see someone
you can never find them. Thing like this made the book relatable to me and I am sure it will have a similar effect with teenagers reading the book.
Obviously
where there’s girls there’s usually boys and we have some strong male characters
within this book such as Rhys and Steve who are also making their own way
through puberty etc.
I
found the book to be an enjoyable read, though at times it became a little bit
confusing trying to keep things straight in my head as I went along. Things
such as which girl was with which boy and then keeping track of which girl had
what secret.
Also at the end of this book is a link to join in the
Wear Blue campaign in November 2019.
The link is: http://www.bullying.co.uk/
I don't have much to say about the ending other than it was overly simplistic considering ALL the drama that happened during the book. Lucy suddenly forgives her friends; and is about to forgive that duckwad of a guy? Perhaps only Ulana's storyline had a satisfactory ending, but then her arc was quite different from the other girls' and it was more of her gaining some sort of courage to tell her parents. Overall, this was a tiresome book to read, even if it has a good message.
ReplyDeleteRiyanna
Believe it, deliverance from generational curses